Question

A paper on this “contested” concept argues that it functions as “magic words” meaning “Hooray for our side!” and cites Judith Shklar’s claim that this ideal is “meaningless thanks to ideological abuse.” This phrase was popularized by A. V. Dicey, who argued that discretion was anathema to this ideal. Ugo Mattei and Laura Nader argue that this ideal legitimized the plunder of colonized nations. This ideal may be present in a society practicing slavery according to scholars like (*) Joseph Raz, who argue that it is procedural and formal. Popular prerequisites (-5[1])for this ideal require government promulgations to be “prospective, open, and clear” and that “natural justice should be observed.” (10[1])This three-word phrase (10[2])names a political ideal that legal bindings apply equally to all people. (-5[1])For 10 points, (10[1])what three-word (10[1])phrase (10[1])names an ideal contrasted with the “rule of man?” ■END■ (10[6]0[1])

ANSWER: rule of law
<JG, Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 Chicago Open07/28/2024Y12100%0%17%128.92

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Ryan Westbrookwhen you look this good, you don’t have to know anythinggenAI this, genAI that, have you found your 真爱 yet89-5
Matt WeinerSAYYID QUTB, DRIVING THE LONGEST CAR YOU’VE EVER SEEN THROUGH TAHRIR SQUARELisan al-Quib10810
Matt JacksonLMM's LLM MLMCharlotte's Moderately Successful Team11110
John MarvinThere are buzzable clues everywhere for those with eyes to seeit's the great pumpkinification objection, charlie brown11110
Joel MilesGalvanized Square Steen and Eco-Friendly Wood VermeerWe Need New Names123-5
Vincent DuA Nervy Liberal Nanny HenceLes Missourables12610
Michael CoatesBerkeley Mafia and the Chicago BoyThe Oldest Men in the World12810
Rasheeq AzadMindgoblin of Little HobbesAMOGH QUIZ HACK? 英雄联盟 400 PPG 24 TUH12910
Caleb KendrickWe Need New NamesGalvanized Square Steen and Eco-Friendly Wood Vermeer13910
Jorrest WeintraubThe Jeam TeamI’ll take a quiet 10 / A handshake of CO (Chicago Open)13910
Tejas RajeBHSU BNJTRANSit (and anwen, I guess)13910
Robert WangNJTRANSit (and bobby, i guess)sticking out your guyot for the ridge push; you're so seafloor spread, you're so fracture zone13910
LouLying on a Mattress at Lou’s Apartment in Pilsen, Chicagovar merchants13910
Rohan Khervar merchantsLying on a Mattress at Lou’s Apartment in Pilsen, Chicago1390
Jason ChenggenAI this, genAI that, have you found your 真爱 yetwhen you look this good, you don’t have to know anything13910