Question

A stringent reading of a theory of this concept seems to entail “zipping back,” in which the actions of persons Y through A become impermissible. Leonard Hobhouse’s distinction of this concept’s “use” and “power” aspects is replaced with a Hegelian “personhood hierarchy” in a paper by Margaret Jane Radin. Calabresi and Melamed distinguished rules of this concept and “liability rules.” A thinker qualified his theory of this concept’s “ingrossment” with the “spoilage condition” and the “enough-and-as-good” clause. (10[1])That thinker (10[1])wrote that “men enter (10[1])into society” to preserve this concept, (-5[1])but constrained its (10[1])creation with a “proviso” (-5[1])that was modified (-5[1])by Robert Nozick. (10[1]-5[3])The Second Treatise (-5[1])argues that this concept (10[1]-5[1])is acquired by (-5[1])mixing (10[2])land and (10[1])labor. (10[3]-5[1])For 10 points, Lockean natural rights entitle one to life, (10[1])liberty, (10[1])and what type of ownership? (10[1])■END■ (10[9])

ANSWER: property [accept right to property, property rights, proprietary, or property rules; accept possessions, estate, title, entitlement, holdings, takings, dominion, dominium, or word forms of any; accept ownership or appropriation or word forms until each is read; prompt on natural rights by asking “to what?”; prompt on justice in holdings]
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y24100%0%42%116.21

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Nathan ZhangCornell AChicago A7610
Forrest WeintraubColumbia ATexas7810
Tim MorrisonStanfordMinnesota A8210
Joseph ChambersVirginiaYale B88-5
Aum MundheRutgersFlorida9110
Justin HawkinsIndianaPurdue95-5
Matthew LehmannWUSTL ANorth Carolina A98-5
Cory SmithKentuckyHarvard10110
Caleb KendrickMarylandToronto A101-5
Chris SimsNorthwesternBrown101-5
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BTruman State101-5
Gabrielle ClarkOttawaPenn104-5
Jaik HavlickArizona StateClaremont Colleges10810
James StevensonMichiganNYU108-5
Neal JoshiWUSTL BColumbia B111-5
Robert CondronChicago BWaterloo11210
Matthew SiffYale ABerkeley A11210
Simon GorbatyDukeToronto B11410
Michael HundingIllinoisGeorgia Tech11510
Conor ThompsonIowa StateJohns Hopkins115-5
William HoustonChicago DMinnesota B11510
Asha BasuMcGillSouth Carolina11510
Graham TroyNorth Carolina BCornell B12510
Max HodesChicago CVanderbilt12610
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina AWUSTL A13110
David BassJohns HopkinsIowa State13210
Sky LiToronto AMaryland13210
Jacob Hardin-BernhardtNYUMichigan13210
Jason HongBrownNorthwestern13210
Danny HanPennOttawa13210
Quynh PhungPurdueIndiana13210
Fred GarveyTruman StateBerkeley B13210
Ben SterlingYale BVirginia13210
John John GrogerColumbia BWUSTL B13210