Question

A stringent reading of a theory of this concept seems to entail “zipping back,” in which the actions of persons Y through A become impermissible. Leonard Hobhouse’s distinction of this concept’s “use” and “power” aspects is replaced with a Hegelian “personhood hierarchy” in a paper by Margaret Jane Radin. Calabresi and Melamed distinguished rules of this concept and “liability rules.” A thinker qualified his theory of this concept’s “ingrossment” with the “spoilage condition” and the “enough-and-as-good” clause. (10[1])That thinker (10[1])wrote that “men enter (10[1])into society” to preserve this concept, (-5[1])but constrained its (10[1])creation with a “proviso” (-5[1])that was modified (-5[1])by Robert Nozick. (10[1]-5[3])The Second Treatise (-5[1])argues that this concept (10[1]-5[1])is acquired by (-5[1])mixing (10[2])land and (10[1])labor. (10[3]-5[1])For 10 points, Lockean natural rights entitle one to life, (10[1])liberty, (10[1])and what type of ownership? (10[1])■END■ (10[9])

ANSWER: property [accept right to property, property rights, proprietary, or property rules; accept possessions, estate, title, entitlement, holdings, takings, dominion, dominium, or word forms of any; accept ownership or appropriation or word forms until each is read; prompt on natural rights by asking “to what?”; prompt on justice in holdings]
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y24100%0%42%116.21

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Nathan ZhangCornell AChicago A7610
Forrest WeintraubColumbia ATexas7810
Tim MorrisonStanfordMinnesota A8210
Joseph ChambersVirginiaYale B88-5
Aum MundheRutgersFlorida9110
Justin HawkinsIndianaPurdue95-5
Matthew LehmannWUSTL ANorth Carolina A98-5
Caleb KendrickMarylandToronto A101-5
Chris SimsNorthwesternBrown101-5
Cory SmithKentuckyHarvard10110
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BTruman State101-5
Gabrielle ClarkOttawaPenn104-5
Jaik HavlickArizona StateClaremont Colleges10810
James StevensonMichiganNYU108-5
Neal JoshiWUSTL BColumbia B111-5
Matthew SiffYale ABerkeley A11210
Robert CondronChicago BWaterloo11210
Simon GorbatyDukeToronto B11410
Michael HundingIllinoisGeorgia Tech11510
Conor ThompsonIowa StateJohns Hopkins115-5
Asha BasuMcGillSouth Carolina11510
William HoustonChicago DMinnesota B11510
Graham TroyNorth Carolina BCornell B12510
Max HodesChicago CVanderbilt12610
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina AWUSTL A13110
Quynh PhungPurdueIndiana13210
David BassJohns HopkinsIowa State13210
Sky LiToronto AMaryland13210
Jacob Hardin-BernhardtNYUMichigan13210
Jason HongBrownNorthwestern13210
Fred GarveyTruman StateBerkeley B13210
Ben SterlingYale BVirginia13210
John John GrogerColumbia BWUSTL B13210
Danny HanPennOttawa13210