Question

Two answers required. Four models of the relationship between these two roles, including the informative and deliberative, are outlined in an Ezekiel Emanuel article. Drawing from Arthur Kleinman’s work, Rita Charon has emphasized the importance of “narrative competence” in the relationship between these roles. The IoM's Crossing the Quality Chasm coined a now-widespread approach “centered” around one of these roles to encourage active participation (15[1]-5[1])and discourage paternalism. Talcott Parsons argued that people in one of these roles enter a state of (*) “sanctioned deviance” policed (-5[1])by those in the other. Principles like informed consent and a namesake sort of “confidentiality” (10[1])for interactions between people in these roles are enforced by HIPAA. For 10 points, what two roles are covenanted by the Hippocratic Oath? ■END■ (10[1])

ANSWER: patients AND doctors [accept answers like physicians, providers, clinicians, specific types of doctors like psychiatrists, or other kinds of healthcare workers like nurses or PAs in place of “doctors”; accept answers like sick or injured in place of “patients”; accept surrogates in place of “patients”]
<VD, Social Science>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Jonathan HaimowitzALCUAnderson et al.6315
Will AlstonSGV VenturesJason et al.63-5
Gary LinU[C]SDClaremont83-5
Akshay SeetharamClaremontU[C]SD9810
Jason ChengJason et al.SGV Ventures12210

Summary