Question

A critic of this framework’s “way,” Deborah Mayo, holds that her “severity account” better handles irrelevant conjunctions in “tacking paradoxes.” The Judy Benjamin problem reveals an ambiguity in this framework, whose synchronic norms include Bas van Fraassen’s (“FRAH-sun’s”) Reflection Principle. (10[1])In a book titled for this framework “or Bust,” John Earman formalized its “folklore” of “washing out,” its threat (10[1])by the old evidence (10[1])problem, and its triumph over the hypothetico-deductive model of confirmation. (10[1])In a field of epistemology named for this framework, gambling-based Dutch Book (10[1])arguments (10[1])are used (10[1])to (10[1])justify requirements like Jeffrey Conditionalization. Subjectivists in this framework (10[2])place no constraints on agents’ initial credences. For 10 points, frequentism (10[1])opposes (10[3])what approach (10[4])in which prior (10[1])probabilities are updated via an (10[1])eponymous theorem? ■END■ (10[1])

ANSWER: Bayesianism (“BAYS-ian-ism”) [or Bayesian inference or Bayesian probability or Bayesian theories; accept Thomas Bayes, Bayes’s theorem, Bayesian epistemology, Bayesian subjectivism, Bayesian confirmation theory, or Bayes or Bust?; prompt on subjectivism or subjective or personalism; prompt on conditionalization by asking “conditionalization a principle in what broader framework?”]
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y21100%0%0%94.38

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Caleb KendrickMarylandPurdue3810
Connor BlakeChicago BDuke5710
Tim MorrisonStanfordYale B6110
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina ABerkeley B7110
Asha BasuMcGillColumbia A8310
Joel MilesMinnesota ABrown8410
Nathan ZhangCornell AMichigan8610
Seth EbnerJohns HopkinsWUSTL A8710
Yared TadesseCornell BYale A9610
Shiv SeshanChicago DWaterloo9610
Matt JacksonChicago AWUSTL B10710
Sky LiToronto AIndiana10810
Chris SimsNorthwesternTruman State10810
Quentin MotGeorgia TechArizona State10810
Eshan PantNYUHarvard11010
Joseph ChambersVirginiaKentucky11010
Swapnil GargBerkeley AToronto B11010
Rasheeq AzadNorth Carolina BColumbia B11010
Akshay SeetharamClaremont CollegesChicago C11310
Jisoo YooTexasSouth Carolina11810
Conor ThompsonIowa StateFlorida12110