Question

This book contrasts the impossibility of the “changing of genera,” such as blackness becoming a cooking pot, with the possibility of a staff becoming a snake. A reductio in this book that hinges on Jupiter and Saturn’s periods of rotation was repurposed in a later argument against “actual infinities.” Before Peter Olivi or Jean Buridan, this book used the example of a man gazing at two identical dates (10[1])to suggest that God could have chosen any time (10[1])to create the world. This book identifies the idea that God only knows universals, the theory of the world’s “pre-eternity,” (10[1])and the denial of bodily resurrection as the three “irreligious” beliefs among 20 propositions. (10[1])William Lane Craig traced the KCA to this Asharite book, which was rebutted (10[1])by Ibn Rushd. (10[2])For 10 points, (10[1])Aristotelians (10[1])like Ibn Sina (10[1])are the target of what treatise (10[4])by al-Ghazali? (10[2])■END■ (10[4])

ANSWER: The Incoherence of the Philosophers [or Tahāfut al-Falāsifa’; prompt on the Incoherence or the Tahāfut] (The KCA is the Kalam Cosmological Argument.)
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y20100%0%0%126.10

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Michal GerasimiukStanfordNorthwestern6710
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina AVirginia7610
Nathan ZhangCornell AToronto B9610
Forrest WeintraubColumbia AClaremont Colleges11010
Jakob MyersIndianaFlorida12310
Andrew KelleyKentuckyToronto A12610
Matt JacksonChicago ASouth Carolina12610
Arthur Delot-VilainYale AWUSTL B12910
Andrew WangIllinoisOttawa13010
Jack RadoColumbia BMichigan13310
Joel MilesMinnesota AChicago C13910
Urbas EkkaMinnesota BDuke13910
Swapnil GargBerkeley ANorth Carolina B13910
Andrew HannaPennMaryland13910
Jason HongBrownMcGill14110
Halle FriedmanNYUJohns Hopkins14110
Aum MundheRutgersHarvard14210
Quynh PhungPurdueTruman State14210
Karthik PrasadCornell BTexas14210
Gavin MarkoffVanderbiltYale B14210