Question

A dialogue starring one of these people and the poet Simonides was the subject of a 1950s correspondence about the feasibility of “Epicurean” (10[2])isolation for philosophers. A pseudo-mathematical passage calculates these people to be 729 times [emphasize] less happy (10[1])than their counterparts. (-5[1])A Xenophon dialogue (-5[1])titled for one of these people is the subject of a Leo Strauss essay “on” them that kicked off his debate with Alexander Kojève (“ko-ZHEV”). One of these people flouted (-5[1])his tutor’s injunction against writing philosophy, according to the Seventh Letter. Plato (10[1])argued that these people are slaves of their own desires (10[1]-5[2])in Book 9 (10[1]-5[1])of the Republic (10[1])and attempted to educate one of them in Sicily. (-5[1])Aristotle (10[2])listed a system named (-5[1])for these people as a “deviant” constitution along with oligarchy and democracy. (10[2]-5[2])For 10 points, (10[1])ancient philosophers debated (10[1])the virtue of killing what absolute rulers? ■END■ (10[7]0[3])

ANSWER: tyrants [or tyrannos; accept word forms like tyranny or tyrannicide; prompt on kings, despots, monarchs, dictators, autocrats, or absolute rulers; prompt on unjust, wicked, evil, or equivalents; reject other titles like “emperor”] (Strauss’s On Tyranny analyzes Xenophon’s dialogue Hiero.)
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y2387%0%43%109.35

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
James StevensonMichiganBerkeley A2210
Jack RadoColumbia BCornell A2210
Forrest WeintraubColumbia ABrown3810
Tim MorrisonStanfordTruman State41-5
Charles HangWUSTL AHarvard44-5
Ezra SantosChicago DToronto B73-5
Matt JacksonChicago ACornell B8510
Maude-Sophie LockmanOttawaClaremont Colleges95-5
Luke SchaarschuchVirginiaIowa State95-5
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina AToronto A9510
Cory SmithKentuckyIndiana9810
Quynh PhungPurdueVanderbilt98-5
Jisoo YooTexasYale A10110
Jack ObermanSouth CarolinaGeorgia Tech110-5
James McCurleyHarvardWUSTL A11110
Jaik HavlickArizona StateWUSTL B11110
Aum MundheRutgersDuke115-5
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BFlorida12710
Justin WytmarIllinoisMcGill12710
Andrew SalijNorthwesternMaryland127-5
Ben SterlingYale BPenn127-5
Robert CondronChicago BNYU13010
Rasheeq AzadNorth Carolina BWaterloo13310
Marcus Forbes-GreenToronto BChicago D14110
Kevin ParkClaremont CollegesOttawa14110
Quentin MotGeorgia TechSouth Carolina1410
Conor ThompsonIowa StateVirginia14110
Jonathan LauJohns HopkinsMinnesota B14110
Urbas EkkaMinnesota BJohns Hopkins1410
Caleb KendrickMarylandNorthwestern14110
Ashish SubramanianDukeRutgers14110
Donal RyanTruman StateStanford14110
Gavin MarkoffVanderbiltPurdue1410