Question

In a “vertical” argument discussed in Robert Fogelin’s book on this thinker’s “crisis,” this thinker suggested that a mathematician checking their work will face an infinite regress of decreasing credences in their judgements. A statement named for this thinker faces the Bad Company problem, since its use of (-5[1])equinumerosity can be swapped out to create more dubious abstraction principles. This thinker suggested that books containing neither “abstract reasoning concerning quantity or number” nor “experimental reasoning” could be committed to flames, (10[2])since they contain (10[1])“nothing but sophistry and illusion.” A “principle” that neo-Fregeans (10[1])(“neo-FRAY-ghee-uns”) use to define numbers is named for this thinker, who grouped mathematical truths as “relations of ideas,” (10[1])not (10[2])“matters (10[1])of fact.” (10[5])For (10[1])10 points, name this author (10[1])of An Enquiry (10[1])Concerning (10[1])Human (10[1])Understanding. (10[1]-5[1])■END■ (10[2])

ANSWER: David Hume [accept Hume’s principle; accept Hume’s Skeptical Crisis]
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y21100%0%10%109.43

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Caleb KendrickMarylandYale B47-5
James StevensonMichiganChicago D7910
Matt JacksonChicago ATexas7910
Quynh PhungPurdueNorthwestern8210
John MarvinChicago BMinnesota B9110
Matthew LehmannWUSTL ANYU10810
Joy AnHarvardDuke10910
Tim MorrisonStanfordVanderbilt10910
Jonathan ShaufNorth Carolina AIowa State11010
Forrest WeintraubColumbia AChicago C11210
Michael HundingIllinoisClaremont Colleges11210
Joel MilesMinnesota AOttawa11210
Danny HanPennTruman State11210
Arthur Delot-VilainYale AGeorgia Tech11210
Liam KusalikWaterlooToronto B11310
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BToronto A11810
Aum MundheRutgersJohns Hopkins12110
Swapnil GargBerkeley ACornell A12210
Jaik HavlickArizona StateSouth Carolina12310
Karthik PrasadCornell BWUSTL B124-5
Hayden PratherFloridaKentucky12410
Amith PunyalaWUSTL BCornell B12510
Ben SterlingYale BMaryland12510