Question

A member of this family attributed his visions of a mummy-like “epileptic patient” to the “French correspondent.” Bernard Williams analyzed a character created by a member of this family to argue that all seemingly “external” reasons are actually “internal.” (10[1])The moral philosophy of a member of this family is the subject of Martha Nussbaum essays like “Finely Aware and Richly Responsible” and “Flawed Crystals.” A member of this family imagined the Mahdī posing him a version of Pascal’s wager, which would be in vain because faith in the Mahdī is a “dead hypothesis” for him. (10[1])A member of this family distinguished types of “options” (10[1])in a lecture (10[2])critiquing a maxim (10[1])condemning belief (10[1])“without sufficient evidence” (10[2])proposed (10[1])by W. K. Clifford. (10[3])For 10 points, name this family of a novelist and his (10[1])brother, (10[2])the author (10[1])of “The Will (10[1])to Believe.” (10[1])■END■ (10[3]0[1])

ANSWER: James family [accept William James; accept Henry James] (The first sentence is from The Varieties of Religious Experience. Williams used “Owen Wingrave” as the main example of “Internal and External Reasons.”)
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y2396%0%0%117.41

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Caleb KendrickMarylandBrown3810
Matt JacksonChicago AWUSTL A9410
Nathan ZhangCornell AStanford10310
Fred GarveyTruman StateChicago C10610
Asha BasuMcGillMinnesota B10610
Jisoo YooTexasNorth Carolina A10910
Jaik HavlickArizona StateFlorida11110
Forrest WeintraubColumbia AChicago B11410
Ben SterlingYale BOttawa11410
Aum MundheRutgersWUSTL B11510
Swapnil GargBerkeley ANorthwestern11910
Kevin ParkClaremont CollegesDuke11910
Joel MilesMinnesota APurdue11910
Andrew WangIllinoisNYU13010
Andrew HannaPennColumbia B13110
Todd MaslykMichiganToronto A13110
Andrew KelleyKentuckySouth Carolina13310
Arthur Delot-VilainYale AJohns Hopkins13610
Rohan ShelkeBerkeley BChicago D13810
Justin HawkinsIndianaWaterloo13910
Quentin MotGeorgia TechIowa State1390
Gavin MarkoffVanderbiltNorth Carolina B13910
Joseph ChambersVirginiaToronto B13910