Question

Kornhauser and Sager’s paradox about a group of three of these people was generalized (10[1])into Philip Pettit’s “discursive dilemma” for belief aggregation. The thesis that these people deal with a defeasible “open texture” was debated by a philosopher who analogized these people to authors of “chain novels.” A slogan of the ALR school defines a related concept as what this sort of person “had for breakfast.” They’re not (10[1])filmmakers, (10[2])but contrasting descriptive and normative theories of how social and personal factors influence these people are called realism and formalism. Against the “no right answer” thesis, a thinker imagined an ideal one of these people (10[1])who would prefer (10[1])an “integrity”-based theory and named him “Hercules.” (10[4])For 10 points, a metaphorical “empire” (10[1]-5[1])titles a Ronald Dworkin book about what (-5[1])job held (10[1])by the scholar (10[1])Richard Posner? (10[1])■END■ (10[6]0[5])

ANSWER: judges [or jurists; or justices; accept Judge Hercules; prompt on legal scholars or law or jurisprudence; reject “lawmakers” or “lawyers” or equivalents of either] (The paradox is the doctrinal paradox. Ronald Dworkin opposed H. L. A. Hart’s theories of defeasibility and “open texture.” ALR is American Legal Realism.)
<Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2024 ACF Nationals2024-04-21Y2387%0%9%109.60

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Caleb KendrickMarylandGeorgia Tech1310
Matthew LehmannWUSTL AWaterloo6710
Todd MaslykMichiganJohns Hopkins6810
Chris SimsNorthwesternNYU6810
Nathan ZhangCornell AIndiana10310
Ethan AshbrookMinnesota AChicago A10610
Andrew WangIllinoisIowa State11310
Forrest WeintraubColumbia ANorth Carolina A11310
Michal GerasimiukStanfordChicago B11310
Aum MundheRutgersToronto B11310
Nathaniel HullBerkeley AToronto A11910
Ryan HumphreyTexasPurdue119-5
Gavin MarkoffVanderbiltMinnesota B126-5
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BNorth Carolina B12810
Luke SchaarschuchVirginiaColumbia B13110
Robert FreemanSouth CarolinaTruman State13310
Arthur Delot-VilainYale ABrown13410
Sarod NoriCornell BChicago C1340
Liam StarnesChicago CCornell B1340
Ezra SantosChicago DHarvard13410
Dean Ah NowClaremont CollegesFlorida13410
Cory SmithKentuckyMcGill13410
Ashish SubramanianDukePenn13410
Andrew HannaPennDuke1340
Eylon CaplanPurdueTexas1340
Urbas EkkaMinnesota BVanderbilt1340
Jaik HavlickArizona StateYale B13410