Question

Description acceptable. In “A New Refutation of Time,” Jorge Luis Borges praises this statement’s “dialectical skill” while discussing the memories conjured by his walks around his neighborhood. In the final paragraph of Fear and Trembling, Søren Kierkegaard (15[1])uses this statement and a later refinement of it (15[1])to illustrate the philosophical impulse to “go further.” Jonathan Barnes stated his preference among Diels and Kranz’s three renderings of this statement by citing its originator’s similar passage about an emulsified drink disintegrating. (15[1])This statement was strengthened to a seemingly (*) nonsensical version (10[1])by a radical disciple (10[1])of its originator named Cratylus. This statement (10[1])is the best-known illustration of a “weeping philosopher’s” (10[1])view that panta rhei, (10[1])or “everything (10[1])flows,” as well as his doctrine of flux. (-5[1])For 10 points, name this aphorism attributed to Heraclitus about entry into a body of water. ■END■ (10[1])

ANSWER: you cannot step in the same river twice [accept equivalent descriptions that mention the inability to enter the same river twice or that a river is never the same twice; accept panta rhei or everything flows until read; prompt on Heraclitus’s doctrine of flux] (Cratylus amended Heraclitus’s claim to “you cannot step in the same river even once.”)
<Tim Morrison, Philosophy>
= Average correct buzz position

Back to tossups

Summary

2023 Chicago Open08/05/2023Y10100%30%10%90.00

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzz PositionValue
Jordan BrownsteinThe Plague (anime)" was redirected to: "Oran High School Host ClubSaint Peter Andre 30003615
Vedul PalavajjhalaI prefer really not to speak. If I speak I’m in big troublewave2: trimming membership codes 9655377758gp4515
Ned TagtmeierIn Search of Things Pastremembrance of lost time7815
Ethan Ashbrook[moderator voice] yes that is so tenpointscore! is your team feeling bonuspilled?I would prefer not to8710
Aseem KeyalThe Catastrophic Implosion of Packet SubCurse you, Periplus the Platypus!9110
Andrew HartBHSUTeam Name Think Detail9810
Andrew WangThe anti-STOON-dahl cabal (the tall Keyal et al.)Romanos IV Diogenes’ Macaroni Grill10610
Charles HangHang et al., Robert BrowningThe Canadians11010
Chris RayTeach Us to Outgrow Our LadnessQuasicrystal Silence11210
Swapnil GargEvans Hall destruction awaitersDon't be Afraid, the Clown's Afraid Too120-5
Mitch McCullarDon't be Afraid, the Clown's Afraid TooEvans Hall destruction awaiters13710