Hesperus AND Phosphorus - 2024 ARCADIA

Question

Two answers required. These two names are argued to have different diagonal propositions in Robert Stalnaker’s 1978 paper “Assertion.” For 10 points each:

[10h] The contrast between the presence of actual identity and lack of necessary identity between what two names was used by Saul Kripke to explain his idea of rigid designators?

ANSWER: Hesperus AND Phosphorus [or the morning star AND evening star]

[10e] Stalnaker used the example of Hesperus and Phosphorus in an influential paper in the “two-dimensional” approach to this field, the study of linguistic meaning, which is often paired with syntax.

ANSWER: semantics

[10m] Two-dimensional semantics extends a semantics based on these entities, which treat meanings as intensions that map from these entities to extensions, or referents. Modal realism holds that these entities truly exist.

ANSWER: possible worlds

<VD, Philosophy>

Back to bonuses

Summary


2024 ARCADIA at BU	2024-12-06	Y	8	8.75	63%	0%	25%
2024 ARCADIA at Duke	2024-12-06	Y	3	20.00	100%	33%	67%
2024 ARCADIA at Missouri S&T	2024-12-06	Y	1	10.00	0%	0%	100%
2024 ARCADIA at Missouri S&T	2024-12-06	Y	2	10.00	50%	50%	0%
2024 ARCADIA Online	2025-05-17	Y	5	14.00	100%	40%	0%
2024 ARCADIA at Penn State	2024-12-06	Y	2	15.00	100%	50%	0%
2024 ARCADIA at Florida Tech	2024-12-06	Y	4	7.50	50%	0%	25%
2024 ARCADIA at UC Berkeley	2024-12-06	Y	2	30.00	100%	100%	100%
2024 ARCADIA at Waterloo	2024-11-09	Y	6	23.33	100%	50%	83%
2024 ARCADIA at GT	2024-12-06	Y	4	7.50	75%	0%	0%
2024 ARCADIA at Illinois	2024-11-09	Y	4	10.00	75%	0%	25%
2024 ARCADIA at Warwick	2024-12-06	Y	5	12.00	80%	20%	20%
2024 ARCADIA at Claremont	2024-11-02	Y	3	10.00	100%	0%	0%

Data


Maryland	Penn State	0	10	0	10
RIT	Pitt	0	10	10	20
UCF A	Florida Tech	10	10	0	20
UF A	UCF B	0	0	0	0
UF B	USF	0	10	0	10
Warwick A	Cambridge B	0	10	0	10
LSE B	Imperial B	0	10	0	10
LSE A	Southampton	0	10	0	10
Cambridge A	Warwick B	10	10	10	30
North Carolina A	South Carolina	10	10	10	30
Virginia Tech B	North Carolina B	10	10	0	20
Virginia Tech A	Virginia Tech C	0	10	0	10
Truman	Missouri	10	0	0	10
Squidward Community College	Missouri	0	0	0	0
WashU	Truman	0	10	10	20
she limp on my waltz till i feel pathetique	ASU->Stanford->ASU pipeline	0	10	0	10
The cult of SGA	In the Mood for Buzz	0	10	0	10
Social credit go vroom	Madmen and Specialists	0	10	10	20
Paddington in Peru (2024)	Old and Young	0	10	10	20
bingy academy	Toyota Tundra Turbos — Twisting Truths - Tackling Trivia - Taming Titans	0	10	0	10
Georgia Tech A	Innovation Academy B	0	10	0	10
Georgia Tech C	Johns Creek	0	10	0	10
Georgia Tech D	Georgia Tech B	0	0	0	0
Lambert	Mississippi State	0	10	0	10
Chicago A	Illinois Orange	10	10	0	20
Chicago B	Illinois Blue	0	0	0	0
Notre Dame	Purdue A	0	10	0	10
Purdue B	SIUE	0	10	0	10
Bowdoin A	Boston College B	0	0	0	0
Brandeis B	Bowdoin B	0	10	0	10
Brandeis A	Bowdoin C	0	10	0	10
Boston College A	Clark House	0	0	0	0
Tufts A	Clark Wilson	0	10	0	10
Harvard	MIT	10	10	0	20
Amherst	Tufts B	10	0	0	10
Yale	BU	0	10	0	10
UF C	Valencia	0	0	0	0
Berkeley A	Berkeley B	10	10	10	30
Berkeley Past	Stanford	10	10	10	30
McGill A	Toronto Metropolitan A	10	10	10	30
Ottawa Absolomabsolomabsolom	McMaster ApocolocyntosisBidii	0	10	0	10
Toronto B	Carleton A	10	10	0	20
Waterloo Aspidistra	Toronto Chestnut Rice and Kamehameha	10	10	10	30
Waterloo Basic	Toronto Disband the Club 2k24	10	10	0	20
Toronto A	Waterloo Cloze	10	10	10	30
Warwick C	Bristol	0	0	0	0
Jason et al.	ALCU	0	10	0	10
Anderson et al.	Claremont	0	10	0	10
SGV Ventures	U[C]SD	0	10	0	10